|Home||Blog||My books!||Newsletter||Worksheets||Lessons||Videos||Online math resources||Reviews||Curriculum guide|
Maria's Math news - a FREE math newsletter for parents and teachers
Latest from my blog
Various worksheets on TONS of math topics you can generate for free!
Basic operations worksheet generator is updated! Make worksheets for whole numbers or integers - all four operations, including add & subtract or multiply & divide - horizontal or vertical - add a border and/or extra workspace, use a variable, and more.
Advice, reviews, and resources to help you choose a math curriculum!
Online math games, tutorials, and activities
Games you can play online, interactive tutorials, fun math websites and more. Arranged by topic/level for ease of use.
Learn how to TEACH concepts or about general concerns in math education.
In-depth reviews of math products
Math help & tutoring
A list of free message boards, math help websites, and online tutoring services.
Fun and games
I have two games on my site, plus links to many.
Game: Choose Math Operation
Word guess game (easy hangman)
Word guess game (difficult)
High school geometry: why is it so difficult?
It is not any secret that high school geometry with its formal (two-column) proofs is considered hard and very detached from practical life. Many teachers in public school have tried different teaching methods and programs to make students understand this formal geometry, sometimes with success and sometimes not. Of course it is even more difficult for a homeschooling parent This article explores the reasons why a typical geometry course in high school is so difficult for many students, and what could a teacher possibly do to help the situation.
Lack of proof and proving in earlier school years
Since high school geometry is typically the first time that a student encounters formal proofs, this can obviously present some difficulties. It can also lead students to think that two-column proof is the only kind of proof there is—yet that form of proof is almost never used by practicing mathematicians.
It would be easier for students if they had encountered informal proofs and were required to justify their statements and reasoning in earlier school years. This of course would not be on such a formal level as in high school, but simply a mindset of teaching mathematics where mathematical statements and truths are justified, the teacher explains where things come from or why something works—and also the child is asked to provide explanations and justifications.
Lack of understanding of geometry concepts
Two Dutch researchers, Dina van Hiele-Geldof and Pierre van Hiele, suggest that students' geometrical understanding progresses through various levels, which cannot be skipped. These levels are now known as van Hiele levels. Other research supports their theory, and has found that most students enter high school geometry with a low Van Hiele level of understanding. Thus they cannot possibly understand the teaching, since writing formal proofs requires at least a van Hiele level 4.
The levels of van Hiele are (note they can also be numbered from 0 to 4):
This theory is not perfect but based on other research, it seems to model the progress of geometrical thinking. The important point is that a lot of the geometry taught before high school does NOT foster students into higher level of geometrical thinking. A lot of the geometry problems in text books are just calculations of the type, "Calculate the area/circumference/perimeter/radius etc. of this figure." Textbook problems concentrate too much on calculating and using formulas, and not enough on analyzing concepts, making conjectures about the properties, testing them, and studying lots and lots of figures and shapes experimentally. More on this later.
Student's cognitive development
This point ties in with the previous one, but has more to do with the general cognitive development instead of just geometrical reasoning. According to the psychologist Jean Piaget's theory about cognitive development, a person needs to achieve a certain level (called formal operational stage) to be able to reason formally and understand and construct proofs. If a high school student has not achieved that, then it will be very hard to understand the geometry course. Sadly, there is some research suggesting that even most college students have not achieved that level (Ausubel, Novak, and Hanesian 1968).
Continue to part 2: What can be done to make high school geometry less of a pain?
Sources and resources
Van Hiele model from Wikipedia
Research Sampler 8. Students' Difficulties with Proof by Keith Weber
What is proof? Do you need proof before high school? - my article.
I have reviewed several geometry books:
Geometry: Seeing, Doing, Understanding by Harold JacobsGeometry: A Guided Inquiry by Chakerian, Crabill, and Stein, and its supplement "Home Study Companion - Geometry" by David Chandler.
Dr. Math geometry books - these are inexpensive companions to middle and high school geometry courses.